Files
searchi/fixtures/relevance-v2/review-history/blind-review-before-correction.json
T

576 lines
29 KiB
JSON

{
"version": 2,
"reviewer": "independent AI agent blind review; not human annotation",
"inputPath": "fixtures/relevance-v2/blind-review-input.json",
"inputSHA256": "b417c45920b4564e07c159f7fd71df58f947eecb178963c1f0fda28ebaeb927f",
"blindness": "No author labels, ranking results, model outputs or query runtime read. Required project instructions and input-listed local sources/licenses only.",
"assetSHA256Verified": true,
"queries": [
{
"id": "bicycle-target-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"bicycle-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "bicycle-target-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"bicycle-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "bicycle-contrast-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"bicycle-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "bicycle-contrast-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"bicycle-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "bicycle-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "bicycle-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "bakery-target-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"bakery-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "bakery-target-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"bakery-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "bakery-contrast-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"bakery-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "bakery-contrast-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"bakery-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "bakery-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "bakery-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "meter-target-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"meter-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "meter-target-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"meter-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "meter-contrast-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"meter-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "meter-contrast-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"meter-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "meter-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "meter-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "museum-target-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"museum-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "Source states a loan rule, not a complete executed agreement; accepted under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "museum-target-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"museum-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "Source states a loan rule, not a complete executed agreement; accepted under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "museum-contrast-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"museum-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "museum-contrast-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"museum-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "museum-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "museum-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "irrigation-target-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"irrigation-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "irrigation-target-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"irrigation-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "irrigation-contrast-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"irrigation-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "irrigation-contrast-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"irrigation-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "irrigation-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "irrigation-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "ferry-target-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"ferry-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "ferry-target-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"ferry-a"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested cracked-weld warranty, almond batch-release, moving-day meter photo, return-transit insurance, low-tank pump shutdown, or missing-crew cancellation rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "ferry-contrast-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"ferry-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "ferry-contrast-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"ferry-b"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Source contains the requested tariff, delivery packing, November radiator, twice-daily humidity, winter hose storage, or bicycle ferry fare rule respectively.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "ferry-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "ferry-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "pattern-build-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-pattern"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Executable Builder::add/extend/build accumulates bytes and constructs configured Searcher state; Searcher::find_in caps the haystack at span.end and starts search at span.start.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "pattern-build-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-pattern"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Executable Builder::add/extend/build accumulates bytes and constructs configured Searcher state; Searcher::find_in caps the haystack at span.end and starts search at span.start.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "pattern-range-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-pattern"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "find_in returns the first match of any configured pattern; enumeration of all bounded matches is not implemented by this method.",
"reason": "Executable Builder::add/extend/build accumulates bytes and constructs configured Searcher state; Searcher::find_in caps the haystack at span.end and starts search at span.start.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "pattern-range-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-pattern"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "find_in returns the first match of any configured pattern; enumeration of all bounded matches is not implemented by this method.",
"reason": "Executable Builder::add/extend/build accumulates bytes and constructs configured Searcher state; Searcher::find_in caps the haystack at span.end and starts search at span.start.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "pattern-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "pattern-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "version-parse-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-version"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Version::from_str parses and validates numeric, prerelease and build components. VersionReq::from_str and recursive version_req contain executable WildcardNotTheOnlyComparator checks.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "version-parse-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-version"
],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "Version::from_str parses and validates numeric, prerelease and build components. VersionReq::from_str and recursive version_req contain executable WildcardNotTheOnlyComparator checks.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "version-wildcard-en",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-version"
],
"confidence": "medium",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "Standalone */x/X mixed with other comparators is rejected; numeric partial wildcard comparators are allowed.",
"reason": "Version::from_str parses and validates numeric, prerelease and build components. VersionReq::from_str and recursive version_req contain executable WildcardNotTheOnlyComparator checks.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Confirm standalone wildcard intent; blanket wildcard rejection interpretation would be false."
]
},
{
"id": "version-wildcard-de",
"expectedIDs": [
"code-version"
],
"confidence": "medium",
"label": "relevant_operative_content",
"ambiguityReason": "Standalone */x/X mixed with other comparators is rejected; numeric partial wildcard comparators are allowed.",
"reason": "Version::from_str parses and validates numeric, prerelease and build components. VersionReq::from_str and recursive version_req contain executable WildcardNotTheOnlyComparator checks.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Confirm standalone wildcard intent; blanket wildcard rejection interpretation would be false.",
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
},
{
"id": "version-absent-en",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": []
},
{
"id": "version-absent-de",
"expectedIDs": [],
"confidence": "high",
"label": "clear_absent_artifact",
"ambiguityReason": "No material ambiguity under required_artifact operative-rule definition.",
"reason": "The requested specific artifact or implementation is absent from every inspected source; shared company/entity or topic does not satisfy the request.",
"sourceQueryMismatch": [
"Actual German input mojibake; labels infer intended recoverable German wording consistently with English pair. Repair encoding before inference."
]
}
],
"evaluationAssessment": {
"meaningfulTextAbstention": true,
"meaningfulCodeAbstention": true,
"limits": [
"Small fictional corpus, unusually explicit rules and contrasts; not representative customer diversity.",
"Specific absent-artifact queries are distinct from broad-topic retrieval; no broad-topic queries are included.",
"Two real code files and far-away negatives do not cover near-miss implementations or overloaded symbols.",
"EN/DE pairs are correlated observations.",
"German mojibake requires repair and refreshed input provenance.",
"Provisional AI review; human annotation and inference remain unperformed."
],
"humanReviewRemaining": [
"Confirm German repair and pair parity.",
"Confirm standalone wildcard intent.",
"Confirm first-match rather than all-match interpretation of bounded pattern request.",
"Confirm museum operative-rule summary qualifies as requested agreement."
]
}
}